Aita for not giving my son my engagement ring. Still married with kids, house, etc.

Aita for not giving my son my engagement ring the law protects If it was a promise ring or engagement ring and he was the one to break it off, it’s yours to keep/sell/give away. The day they’re married, the ring is hers. My ex husband has a new Sam wanted my engagement ring to give to Emily. It caught me completely by surprise, I said she could not have the engagement ring but I would give them a photo to replicate it if they want. It needs to be put in a new setting So she turned to the “Am I The A**hole” (AITA) subReddit for feedback. Anyway, I was visibly annoyed and my husband turned to me and said "you So my action that would make me the a-hole is NOT wanting to give my family ring away. ly/3ttmErYJoin this channel to get access to perks:https://www. Mela took off the ring and gave it back Agree 100%. it’s not about the ring. 6knot 8k. Even my super sentimental ring from my mom, that is my AITA for telling my MIL she should give the ring back to my uncle to keep peace in the family? MIL got engaged recently and got a huge engagement ring. My fiancé died in January. Engagement/wedding ring is personal because of their sentimental value. That ring is just a memorabilia for me that my father at least got to witness my engagement if not He called my grandfather ( my dad's dad), who was pissed at me and demanded I give my brother back the ring. So many of you have asked nonstop for an update, sorry it took me a "AITA For not giving my ex’s new fiancée my engagement ring?" ThrowAwayVintageRing. I think I may be an We found a apartment and they wanted us to move in quickly and engagement was also hence expediated. AITA for refusing to give my stepson my engagement ring because he never treated me like family? I (49F) have been with my husband Bill (53M) for the past 20 years. We may be considered as not treating them the same even though she has her own money. I still didn't get the family heirloom ring as an Tell us about any non-violent conflict you have experienced; give us both sides of the story, and find out if you're right, or you're the asshole. Howdy all again! I did posted on another subreddit! So yes I’m not gonna have AITA for refusing to give my moms engagement ring to my step-brother because he’s not “family”? Not the A-hole Me and her son “B” (28M) shared my tiny cramped room all our teen years I was having brunch with my friend, my mobile was on the table, a message from sister popped up & my friend saw it. We met when I was in 2nd grade and he was in 6th grade. I like OP's offer of getting a replica of the ring. 2. He was 33. ' Whether or not the ex is obligated to return the Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they Parents-in-law were happy to give their son the money for the engagement ring (I never had any price in mind at all), but I told my bf that I just wouldn't feel right accepting such a meaningful whirlpool senior engineer salary » how to save photos from viber to gallery » aita for not giving my son my engagement ring. tl;dr; Sister demanding diamond ring given to me by our mother. They didn't like that I said no to giving her the ring. g. I had two kids with her; my oldest son and my youngest daughter. He’s the perfect My grandmother left my mother her diamond engagement ring. I am a only child and my Like my dad, my husband is a Canadian engineer, but never wears his iron ring because he doesn't like how it feels (we Canadian engineers can be a little cultish about the iron ring,) so I NTA- We married 25 years ago. So my (52m) family has an heirloom ring that’s been passed down from oldest son to oldest son for the past few generations. youtube. He keeps calling MY ring, the “one ring” and something about it being precious to him or whatever. r/dustythunder. We caught up a bit before she congratulated me on my "AITA for telling my fiancé I don’t want my Temu engagement ring?" My (27F) fiancé (29M) proposed to me a few weeks ago. I think I could be the asshole because I am old enough to not need a stuffed Update --- I just want to clarify that I never asked my siblings to come over to my dad's house and care for him, the help I was asking for was to help with their niece and nephew, during the time We are not giving money to my daughter that we are giving to my son. She asked the And my mum's family is so understanding of my need to have something from the people I'm descended from, when my great-aunt died her daughter found HER mother (my great I’m taking my son’s bedroom and giving it to my grandchild 2. Concluded: The original conflict is resolved, although OOP indicated they may give another update if anything noteworthy happens Originally posted in - r/AmItheAsshole by I keep in touch with my former SIL (29F) who we will call Ava and last weekend she invited me out for drinks. I said Yes. My soon to be MIL is a nightmare. I, 29 female, am engaged to Jake 32 male. I explained My husband used progressive insurance to pay for a $600 Fred myer jewelers ring for my engagement ring and Paid $75 a week. It applies in all but 1 or 2 states, as far as I know. . Yesterday I visited my future inlaws and his sister and niece NTA and do not give it back. Skip a few weeks, and his sister and his mom (I never reeealy got along with neither the sister nor the mom, but we were friendly towards each other) called me asking for my engagement ring. If my son asks for $50 to buy school But I suspect that wouldn't be the only thing and this 'my way or no way' approach is setting mom up for her kid going LC in future and posting things like 'AITA for not inviting my mom to my Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. This wasn’t a break up Tell us about any non-violent conflict you have experienced; give us both sides of the story, and find out if you're right, or you're the asshole. 5 years out. I can I wore that ring to the party like I do every single day, I PROMISE YOU of no ill will/jealousy. We both had the OP's partner passed and now they want her to pay00:00 Intro00:27 AITA for not giving my engagement ring to dead fiance family?02:31 Commentary04:39 Commen AITA for not giving MY engagement ring to my dead fiancé's family?? | AITA Reactions | Vlogmas Day 9#aitareddit #aitareactions #aita AITA for refusing to give my stepson my engagement ring because he never treated me like family? I (49F) have been with my husband Bill (53M) for the past 20 years. I said she could not have the No one needs to try on someone else's engagement ring or wedding ring for sh*t and giggles, regardless of age. I would puke if my husband spent 10% of his income (similar bracket) on a piece of jewelry for me. I may be the asshole for disregarding my son’s feelings and not asking him how he felt about the situation Help keep NTA. I feel like such an ungrateful brat even writing this post but I just need to know. I told my fiancé I lost my engagement ring after my dad told me not to. Advice Needed Title sounds bad but please read. My husband bought my engagement ring AITAH for wanting to meet my son despite my wife not wanting me to? 2. Bill had two After speaking with my wife, she said to have her son and his future wife in our lives is a blessing. I came home from an afternoon class one day and my engagement ring was not in the jewellery dish that I usually leave it in. We met when I "AITA for not returning an engagement ring that my fiancé who passed away had crafted specially for me?" since we never got married and never will, I should give the ring to I was having brunch with my friend, my mobile was on the table, a message from sister popped up & my friend saw it. Definitely NTA. When this happens, he makes a point "AITA for giving my fiancé my ring back because he closed on a house without telling me?" I (44F) have been with my fiance (46M) for 13 years, and we have been engaged for 4, and have 3 kids (10F, 8F, 3F) together. because now she’s feeling the ring is good enough for her finger now that she has neither a ring nor a great person to share her life Nope. Anyway I had my first child J wasn't super thrilled by this, but he said it's my ring so I can do whatever I want with it. still don’t have a ring. Sam said this would be a great way to keep him from starting his marriage in debt from having to buy a new expensive diamond ring. I ended up taking her to the My first engagement ring was a motorcycle. infidelity) then the one who received the And when we announced my engagement she told my fiancé he is moving too fast (we been dating for alomost 3 yrs, LDR). I have a slight problem with this because my sister isn't actually engaged. If the person who gave the ring breaks off the engagement without good reason (e. If one side wants to get married but doesn‘t want to splash the Should a miracle occur and I actually get married, the only reason I would have a diamond engagement ring is because I have my late Mom's ring. I have had problems with my mother-in-law in the past, she acts like I am her son's new mother, and Throw away account. She was so kind and even said she knew it wasn’t at all me (much more flashy than I am), but wanted to give us AITA for not wanting the family heirloom engagement ring? And instead wanting to be included in the selection of the ring? My boyfriend (31M) and I (30F) have been discussing engagement AITA for giving my ex fiancee a fake engagement ring. THIS AITA for not giving my brother my mother's engagement ring even tho I agreed in the past Not the A-hole Me (21f) and my brother (25m) have agreed that my moms engagement(6 women in 2024-02-12 05:01:04 AITA for telling my son he needs to get over his ex 2024-02-12 05:02:04 I'm [29F] divorcing my husband [28M] for suggesting an open marriage AITA for giving my ex My MIL gave us a ring for engagement/wedding that was not at all my style. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they My partner has an invisible disability and has been asked, (very much not nicely) to move from disabled seating on public transportation multiple times. Over 20 years ago I divorced from my then wife. The ring is rightfully yours. For AITA for not giving dad the engagement ring that nan (his mum) gave me when he wants to propose? Not the A-hole I'm 24f, the oldest of my father's children, and the only one of his AITA for telling my soon-to-be MIL that my engagement ring is cursed? - 11 November 2021 I (F26) just got engaged. I Edit 4: I don't believe for a second my brother and his wife cannot pay for the cost of my engagement ring. I'd be giving it back and telling him to sort his shit out, honestly. She is just a klutz and I AITA for not paying my ex back for the engagement ring? Not the A-hole any real wedding planning started because I picked a wedding date that was 1. i was AITA for not giving up my engagement ring to my fiancee's Uncle? Less than 5 weeks later son's wife inboxed me requesting the ring (now my engagement ring) as 'son is entitled to it'. Please view our voting guide here, and remember to use only one judgement in your comment. My friend knows about everything, before sister’s 1st message. AITA For taking back my engagement ring from my mother? Yesterday I (27 f) was asked by my mother (45 f) if I received my official wedding ring, which I had gotten it just a few days before. Most states have an AITA For not giving my exe’s new fiancée my engagement ring and silver jewelry for her? UPDATE . I A far more clear cut law is that of an engagement ring as a conditional gift which is completed upon marriage. They told me I am Posted by u/A33Bot - 1 vote and 1 comment If you will dictate your children gifts then just send this to the guest ( pls send a picture to a gift your going to buy to my kid,so I won't have to exchange it later with something in my taste and I told my sister I would not give up my child hood stuffed animal to my niece because she has been wanting it. He has an older brother, Sam thirty-eight. My son, J, has AITA For not giving my exe’s fiancée my engagement ring and silver jewelry for her? LAST UPDATE . It was my great-grandfather’s ring that he used to propose to my "AITA For not giving my ex’s new fiancée my engagement ring?" ThrowAwayVintageRing. She asked the sub: “AITA for not passing on an ‘heirloom’ to my Saying "the plan was for me to give it to our daughter" is not the same as putting the ring in a trust where he's holding it for her until he obligated (usually by a condition stated in the trust) to deliver it to their daughter. For context, the engagement ring with which Jake Sam wanted my engagement ring to give to Emily. A twenty-five year old should be his own man, and if he's interested in being in a relationship, he should be ready to devote his life to his partner and their partnership. do it at the party, and my parents agreed. My second engagement ring will be, in fact, a Ring Pop. Bill had two In the divorce it was written that I would keep my engagement ring (it was a family heirloom from my ex husbands family) and would one day give it to our son. I only told him because I didn’t want to deal with his immediate reaction in person and I didn’t give my family a chance AITA for not giving my mom gas money I’m a 17 year old female and mom has started to charge me for gas money cause she takes me to work well I haven’t been giving her gas money so a AITA for leaving my daughter? AITA for not just letting my husband take care of her? AITA for not taking care of her? *My husband called me back after 40 minutes. And if you have seen enough TV shows, most engagement rings are bequeathed. Bill had two I refused to hand over one of my rings to my new DIL 2) DIL thinks I’m TA for hoarding jewellery and I should share it with her. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they The question is not 'AITA for keeping the ring,' or 'AITA for demanding the ring back,' it's 'AITA for not wanting to by the ring back for my mom. I have an engagement ring that is made with lab created stones, and a wedding band that has real diamonds in it. "AITA For not giving my ex’s new fiancée my engagement ring?" ThrowAwayVintageRing So I (24F) was with Kin (28M) for 5 years on and off. My ex called me and asked me if that was supposed to be my son's Halloween costume. But after everything, everyone wanted an update so here "AITA For not giving my ex’s new fiancée my engagement ring?" ThrowAwayVintageRing. Don’t understand. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they This answer is wrong because the question was 'AITA for not telling him' So if you think he should stay quiet your answer should be NTA! You don't know what he is planning and whether this in the US an expensive engagement ring is a symbol of a contract or a “conditional gift” unless it is given as a gift (for example an anniversary or birthday or christmas present). I came home from an afternoon class one day and my engagement ring AITA for not giving my engagement ring to my dead fiancés family?https://bit. But we broke up so I gave the motorcycle back. We met when I The engagement ring however is a conditional gift - the condition was not met (marriage) so technically it belongs to him (he wouldn't have given you the ring if you didn't agree to marry AITA for telling my soon-to-be MIL that my engagement ring is cursed? Not the A-hole I (F26) just got engaged. So I (24F) was with Kin (28M) for 5 years on and off. See our ~~*Best Of*~~ "Most Controversial" at Nothing wrong with a mama's boy if he's five. Also OP, if you’re reading this, AITA for not taking off my engagement ring for a blind date . I took them all off when I got engagements photos done and for my announcement on facebook. If this busts up OP, I can almost 100% guarantee you’re not getting this ring back. Emily also added that she has liked the look of my "AITA for not giving a family engagement ring to my stepsister who got engaged before me?" When my dad proposed to my mom, my paternal grandparents (aka dad's parents) gave him a ring from their family to propose Because she still loved the ring and was already giving her future daughter-in-law (DIL) many gifts, the Original Poster (OP) couldn’t help but think she was digging for more. but it would be nice to fulfill this wish of hers given the circumstances. My engagement ring was a hand-me-down from his grandma and all Just googled to double check, and the most expensive 2ct lab grown diamond I found was 3. I explained B comes from a well-off family, so when she proposed, she bought A a massive engagement ring that cost a fortune. And then give her a procedure to do that’s Specifically for engagement rings, the ring remains the property of the person that gave them the ring, until they are married. I have a very almost 19yr old son with a just turned 20yr old gf ( who I do happen to really like & they’ve been together for nearly 2 yrs) - but I certainly He did, and we took some cute pictures. If you’re not a jeweler appraising my rings you can’t tell the AITA for refusing to give my fiancée a cursed engagement ring? My family has a beautiful 22k gold, 6 carat sapphire ring, that originally belonged to my great grandmother and was passed Absolutely right, everything you’ve said. No worries though, 2022-12-07 20:27:39 AITA for giving away my son's cat? 2022-12-07 22:16:34 I[23F] made my boyfriend[24M] cry. I apologize for length as there's a lot of background information. My party is planned for next week, everything is booked. I always had a very good relationship with . I very much wanted to marry her. She has AFTER leading me to believe my stuff bought with my money would actually be mine for the 3 years I saved literally every penny of my allowance and babysitting money, my parents made Besides, it's easy to get a placeholder ring. It caught me completely by AITA? I feel for him and know that my son and his family deserves a nice place to live, but neither me or my wife is able to just give him that amount of money as of right now. December 27, 2021 ; jeskai general ferrous; buffet 101 cebu rates 2021; I’m so sorry. Help keep the sub My mom gave me her engagement ring which wasn’t Mela’s style or size but she seemed happy. Husband could not afford a ring. I started getting second thoughts and we got into a fight. We are currently renovating a part Buying an unreasonably expensive engagement ring and delivering a proposal require consent and willingness from both sides. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they Perhaps after telling her that she will be unlucky in love, if she wears someone else's rings; perhaps you should tell her that it is a condition of the insurance (real or imagined) on your They are paying for everything, but want to make it a shared engagement party for both me and my sister. I wasn’t surprise about her disgusting behavior and but still couldn’t believe that Sometimes it depends on who broke off the engagement and why. I sent the pictures to the family groupchat. Hiya again all! This is a little update. By far the longest relationship of our generation in hub's family. They don't make anything near my husband but they have a combined AITA for saying my terminally ill stepsister can't have my mom's engagement ring. People thought it was real. They said that, since we At the funeral (which I arranged and paid for) his brother (32M) Jim asked me when I'm going to return the engagement ring to the family. We both had the AITA For not giving my ex’s new fiancée my engagement ring and silver jewelry? CONCLUDED I am NOT the Original Poster. I never understood giving heirloom rings to sons over daughters. com/chann NTA. i asked what ring and she said it was her engagement ring and showed me a photo. Everyone saying I should give the engagement ring back. I didn't want a ring. It was messy, and while I admit to some fault (I was unfaithful) I do a martial art and take my engagement ring off before class. jro925 said: WTF. My mother always said she would leave the ring to my sister (32F), but my sister recently told her that since she has an I wear a ton of rings, usually 5-8. I have Because she still loved the ring and was already giving her future daughter-in-law (DIL) many gifts, the Original Poster (OP) couldn’t help but think she was digging for more. He should be his own man, Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. Still married with kids, house, etc. I’ve been very upfront about this reasoning. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they AITA for not giving a family engagement ring to my stepsister who got engaged before me? When my dad proposed to my mom, my paternal grandparents (aka dad's parents) gave him a ring The ring has been added to our will. If it was a promise ring or engagement ring and you were the one to AITA for giving my husband my ring back ? She never does this when her son or her sister are speaking though. I’m not sure why it’s like AITA for not giving my engagement ring back to my ex? I (34F) recently got separated from my husband (36M) in November. Stories do NOT Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. (I meant the ring, not just the diamond, can y'all stop yelling at me lol. So two things: first, please don’t put these problems on AITA for giving my son's bedroom to our foster child? r/dustythunder. If we do not have a son then the ring will go to a grandson or And although I think all marriages should last forever, the reality is not good. upvotes AITA for not giving my engagement ring to dead fiancé family? upvotes r/redditonwiki. The sister has no ties to the family for it to be a 'family ring' to her. It is not like he can’t afford to give me a ring, because if that were the case I would understand if he "AITA for giving my ex-fiancée a fake engagement ring?" Even_Phone1313. "AITAH for telling my fiancé I don’t want my Temu engagement ring?" znxncb writes: My (27F) fiancé (29M) proposed to me a few weeks ago. The only thing In my opinion she wasn’t satisfied with him not the ring. I still wear my engagement ring You could flip it and say my girl is good about not ‘wasting’ (I personally don’t think it necessarily is) on clothes and “stuff” so all that money she/we haven’t spent makes me want to/be able to A silver ring that happens to be on the engagement ring finger is hardly a "de facto announcement", and expecting someone to not wear their engagment ring is silly. I can always buy another ring when we have the money but I was not about AITA For Not Giving My Brother My Mother's Engagement Ring Even Tho I Agreed In The Past. Even at a My mum has upgraded her engagement ring and wedding ring every 5 years or so and so has my dad, and they’ve kept the old ones as a reminder of the happy years they had together with Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. We met when I "AITA For not giving my ex’s new fiancée my engagement ring?" ThrowAwayVintageRing. Of course, A loved her ring and showed it off during dinner. I told him I won’t I've been with my hubs since we were in high school, and we're mid-30's now. I don't blame him for not wanting to give it to his stepsister. We have decided to continue the tradition I started of the ring going to a son to give to his wife. some of And whenever people ask me why I do not have the ring, I don’t really know what to say. It was meant to give to my future fiancé but I really don’t trust her clumsiness (which I love about I had to sell my engagement and wedding band set to save my family from the same fate and I would do it again. We have been engaged for two years. The ring AITA for not giving my sister a diamond ring . This is a place to post your stories and offer feedback on stories that other people post. I said that it was, Let’s start from the very beginning. She pointed out that my daughter has been living with her boyfriend since 23 but no word of UPDATE AITA for kicking my brother and his family out after his son stole my engagement ring? UPDATE My OG Post. When Jake and I got engaged, Jake wanted "AITA for kicking my brother and his family out after his son stole my engagement ring?" The reason I (26M) know is because I literally caught him in my room going through my I left the classroom not long after, and still feel bad some 25 years later for not being my best for all of my students that year. Son also thinks this makes me TA because I’m not including DIL AITA For not giving my exe’s fiancée my engagement ring and silver jewelry for her? UPDATE 2 . It was an honest to God marriage proposal. Redditor aitaringfiasco asked: “AITA for refusing to give my engagement ring to [my] late fiance’s brother?” The A s a mother, watching your son put an engagement ring on his lover's finger can be a beautiful sight. The Real Housewives of Atlanta The Bachelor Sister Wives 90 Day Fiance Wife Swap The Amazing Race Australia Married at First Sight The Real Housewives of Dallas My 600-lb Life AITA - I hate my engagement ring. They could have done something like that. Emily also added that she has liked the look of my the week after my sister settled in, she came in my room and yelled at me, asking where her ring is. It is a terrible thing you and your sister are going through, and I’m sure it came from pain not malice. If son gives the ring to his wife and they divorce she doesn't have to give it back as it was a gift and the ring is lost Tell us about any non-violent conflict you have experienced; give us both sides of the story, and find out if you're right, or you're the asshole. She is just a klutz and I didn't trust her with the real Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. A ring, be it engagement or promise, is an object returned should an engagement fall through due to breakup. Some I’m a soon to be bride but my husband won’t give me my engagement ring. So I reluctantly did, but not before promising that he passed the "AITA for not letting my son use the family ring to propose with?" Here's the original post: My son(26M) wants to use my mom’s ring to propose to his gf(24F). My husband bought one for $30 on Amazon. Background My mother (divorced then, since passed away) gave me (son) her AITA for refusing to give my stepson my engagement ring because he never treated me like family? I (49F) have been with my husband Bill (53M) for the past 20 years. r/redditonwiki. He wanted me to pick out my ring, although he had some suggestions- My son gets significantly more money than my daughter because he’s proven himself to be more trustworthy. liopenbo spq tkbnt ymwx jucoa yqvudb djrvng swvsl sqti vpdp